Etsy's Journey Of Building a Marketplace

Founded in 2005, Etsy has revolutionised the online marketplace for handmade and vintage arts and crafts. With its roots in a Brooklyn apartment and its heart in a vibrant community of craft enthusiasts, Etsy has grown into a multi-billion dollar public company. In this article, we will explore the story of Etsy's rise to fame, from its humble beginnings to its current status as a global leader in the world of e-commerce.


The Genesis of Etsy: A Platform for Handmade Goods

In the early 2000s, a craftsman by the name of Rob Kalin found himself searching for a platform to sell his handmade furniture online. Frustrated by the lack of suitable options, he, along with his friends Chris Maguire and Haim Schoppik, decided to create their own online marketplace. The trio spent two and a half months developing the initial version of Etsy, a platform dedicated to the sale of handmade, vintage and craft supplies.

The first item sold on this budding platform was a simple handmade pouch, sold for a modest $8. This marked the beginning of a journey that would see Etsy evolve into a global marketplace with more than 7.5 million sellers and 96 million active buyers.

The Appeal of Marketplaces: A Look at the Mechanics

Marketplaces have existed since the dawn of commerce, serving as a hub for the exchange of goods and services. Despite this, building a successful online marketplace poses a unique set of challenges. Unlike traditional businesses that control their own supply, marketplaces rely on external suppliers to meet demand. This creates a delicate balance that requires careful management to maintain.

The appeal of marketplace businesses lies in their potential for network effects, where the value of the platform increases as more users join. Other benefits include high barriers to entry, efficiency, scalability, and flexibility. However, the challenges associated with maintaining this balance can make the growth of marketplace businesses a complex endeavour.

Kickstarting the Etsy Marketplace: The Chicken-and-Egg Problem

One of the key challenges faced by any marketplace is the classic chicken-and-egg problem. To attract buyers, a marketplace needs sellers, but to attract sellers, it needs buyers. Etsy's solution to this problem was to focus on the supply side of the market. By attending art and craft shows, the founding team was able to connect with potential sellers and build an initial supply base for the marketplace.

In addition to this, Etsy also encouraged sellers to promote their own shops. This created a self-sustaining ecosystem where sellers drove demand, leading to a positive feedback loop that fuelled growth.

Scaling the Etsy Marketplace: Driving Demand

Once Etsy had established a solid base of suppliers, the next challenge was to generate demand. The company took a multi-faceted approach to this, focusing on several key areas.

Firstly, Etsy leveraged the power of word-of-mouth marketing. Sellers were encouraged to promote their shops to their personal networks, creating a buzz around the platform and driving organic growth.

Secondly, Etsy focused on search engine optimisation (SEO). With millions of product listings being indexed by search engines, this drove a significant amount of traffic to the site.

Finally, Etsy capitalised on the self-sustaining ecosystem it had created. Sellers often purchased supplies from other sellers on the platform, creating a seller-buyer-seller loop that further fuelled growth.

The Etsy Phenomenon: A Public Company with a Heart

Despite its commercial success, Etsy has never lost sight of its roots. The company continues to champion the handmade, the unique and the personal. This ethos is reflected in every aspect of the company, from its business practices to its office culture.

At the heart of Etsy's culture is a commitment to diversity and inclusion. This is reflected in its gender-neutral bathrooms, its support for the LGBT+ community, and its efforts to maintain a gender-balanced workforce. Etsy is a company largely run by women, used mostly by female entrepreneurs, to sell to a predominantly female consumer base.

The Etsy Effect: Impact and Influence

Etsy's impact extends beyond its own platform. The company has inspired a wave of similar marketplaces, each catering to a specific niche. However, despite the competition, Etsy has maintained its position as a leader in the field.

This is largely due to the company's unwavering commitment to its mission: to keep commerce human. By focusing on providing special, unique items, Etsy has carved out a niche for itself that is far removed from the commodified world of Amazon and eBay.

The Etsy Strategy: A Masterclass in Marketplace Growth

Etsy's success can be attributed to a number of key strategies. First and foremost is its focus on the supply side of the market. By building a strong base of sellers, Etsy was able to create a self-sustaining ecosystem that drove demand.

Secondly, Etsy leveraged the power of SEO to drive traffic to its site. With millions of listings being indexed by search engines, Etsy was able to capture a significant amount of organic traffic.

Finally, Etsy understood the importance of community. The company fostered a sense of community among its sellers, encouraging them to support each other and promote their shops. This created a positive feedback loop that fuelled growth.

The Future of Etsy: Continuing to Innovate in the Face of Change

Despite its success, Etsy is not resting on its laurels. The company continues to innovate and adapt in response to the changing landscape of e-commerce. This is reflected in its recent decision to let its B Corp certification lapse in order to focus on helping sellers increase their sales.

However, despite these changes, Etsy remains committed to its mission of keeping commerce human. The company continues to champion the handmade and the unique, ensuring that its platform remains a beacon for craft enthusiasts around the world.

Concluding Thoughts: Lessons from the Etsy Story

The story of Etsy's rise to fame offers a wealth of lessons for aspiring entrepreneurs and business leaders. At the heart of these lessons is a deep understanding of the mechanics of marketplace businesses and the unique challenges they present.

By focusing on the supply side of the market, leveraging the power of SEO, and fostering a sense of community among its sellers, Etsy was able to overcome the chicken-and-egg problem and build a successful, sustainable marketplace.

As Etsy continues to grow and adapt in the face of change, it will be interesting to see how the company navigates the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead.

In the meantime, Etsy's story serves as a testament to the power of innovation, determination, and a deep understanding of the market. It reminds us that with the right strategies and a little bit of luck, it is possible to carve out a unique niche in even the most crowded of marketplaces.

Back to blog

Stories for Startups.

Get Smarter Every Week - We Send You Cool Stories About People Making Money, and Tell You How They Did It.

Stop anytime.